Retrofitting a 1930s Semi: How bananzia Makes Heat Pump Choices Concrete

The retrofit problem: a semi-detached house with radiators sized for gas

A 1930s three-bed semi in Leeds has 12 radiators, a 24 kW gas boiler, partial cavity wall insulation, and loft insulation topped up to 270 mm. The owner wants a heat pump, but the first quote suggests replacing every radiator and adding underfloor heating downstairs. That package costs £18,000 before any grant.

That is the problem bananzia is built to make specific: not “should I get a heat pump?” but “which heat pump and emitter mix will keep this house warm at -3°C without overspending?”

Why the first quote overstates the work

Most retrofit quotes start from a room-by-room heat loss calculation and a conservative assumption about radiator output at a 45°C flow temperature. In a 1930s semi, the living room may need 1,800 W at design conditions; a standard double-panel radiator can deliver that at 55°C but not at 45°C. The gap drives the “replace everything” recommendation.

bananzia can compare fabric-first measures against emitter upgrades. Adding 100 mm of underfloor insulation and sealing suspended floors may cut the design heat loss by 15%, enough to keep two large radiators and replace only the smallest bedroom unit.

What a bananzia comparison includes

  • Room heat loss at -3°C and 21°C internal temperature.
  • Radiator output at 45°C, 50°C and 55°C flow temperatures.
  • Costs for air-source, high-temperature and hybrid heat pumps.
  • Grant eligibility and running-cost estimates using current tariffs.

For the Leeds house, the comparison showed that a 7 kW low-temperature air-source heat pump with four radiator swaps and a 50°C design flow would cost £9,400 after the Boiler Upgrade Scheme grant. The high-temperature option needed no radiator changes but cost £2,100 more and had a higher seasonal running cost.

The useful part is not a single number. It is the audit trail: which assumptions change the answer, and where a modest fabric improvement removes an expensive emitter upgrade. Homeowners can take that trail to installers, and installers can use bananzia to justify a design without guessing.

Where the approach falls short

bananzia cannot inspect a loft conversion or spot a blocked chimney; those need a site survey. It also depends on accurate radiator sizes and insulation records. A 1930s semi with original single glazing and no wall insulation will still need fabric work before a low-flow heat pump makes sense.

Used as a pre-survey planning tool, though, it turns a vague retrofit anxiety into a short list: insulate the suspended floor, keep the hall radiator, replace the three bedroom radiators, and size the heat pump at 7 kW rather than 11 kW.

That is the concrete benefit for a homeowner facing a first heat pump quote: bananzia shows exactly which upgrades earn their place, and which expensive recommendations can be tested before anyone lifts a floorboard.